Portnoy slams Floyd album as 'disrespectful'
Outspoken drummer says 'real' Pink Floyd is only when Gilmour and Waters work together
Select the newsletters you’d like to receive. Then, add your email to sign up.
You are now subscribed
Your newsletter sign-up was successful
Want to add more newsletters?
Every Friday
Louder
Louder’s weekly newsletter is jam-packed with the team’s personal highlights from the last seven days, including features, breaking news, reviews and tons of juicy exclusives from the world of alternative music.
Every Friday
Classic Rock
The Classic Rock newsletter is an essential read for the discerning rock fan. Every week we bring you the news, reviews and the very best features and interviews from our extensive archive. Written by rock fans for rock fans.
Every Friday
Metal Hammer
For the last four decades Metal Hammer has been the world’s greatest metal magazine. Created by metalheads for metalheads, ‘Hammer takes you behind the scenes, closer to the action, and nearer to the bands that you love the most.
Every Friday
Prog
The Prog newsletter brings you the very best of Prog Magazine and our website, every Friday. We'll deliver you the very latest news from the Prog universe, informative features and archive material from Prog’s impressive vault.
Mike Portnoy has slammed news of a first Pink Floyd album in 20-years as "disrespectful".
The former Dream Theater and current The Winery Dogs drummer is a self-proclaimed Floyd fanatic and he took to his official Facebook page to hit out at the news that Floyd will release new album The Endless River in October.
He says: “What’s this about a new Pink Floyd album? Last I checked, Waters is no longer in the band and Wright and Barrett are dead. If these are leftovers from The Division Bell sessions, then just put them on a The Division Bell special-edition release.
“It’s disrespectful to Roger and everything he built for all those years. Just do a solo album, Dave. In my opinion, the Pink Floyd heyday was Atom Heart Mother through The Wall, and those were mainly driven by Roger – conceptually, musically, everything.
”A Momentary Lapse Of Reason and The Division Bell are essentially David Gilmour solo albums ‘as’ Pink Floyd – granted, just as The Final Cut was a Roger Waters solo album ‘as’ Pink Floyd .
“If you really want, I’ll meet you, Gilmour fans, halfway and at least concede with saying, okay, ‘real’ Pink Floyd is really only when Waters and Gilmour work together.”
Floyd’s first album since 1994’s The Division Bell was revealed via Twitter by Gilmour’s wife Polly Samson and later confirmed by the band.
The latest news, features and interviews direct to your inbox, from the global home of alternative music.
