Son: “I straight-up do not remember.” Dad: “Really?” Watch Mike Portnoy discover Max doesn’t recall the Dream Theater split – even though he was there when it began

Max Portnoy tells Mike Portnoy he remembers nothing about the Dream Theater split
(Image credit: YouTube)
0

Mike Portnoy’s son Max was on the road with his dad when his split with Dream Theater began to take shape – but the younger drummer doesn’t remember any of it.

In 2010, while touring with Avenged Sevenfold, Portnoy Sr wanted to take a hiatus from the prog metal giants he’d co-founded, only to be told his colleagues didn’t want the same. That led to his departure and a 13-year split that ended with their reunion in 2023.

The DT co-founder has often discussed his feelings about the drama, including suffering from stress and overwork combined with a desire to explore other musical directions. It can only have been a harrowing period for his entire family.

The Real Story Behind Mike Portnoy Leaving Dream Theater - YouTube The Real Story Behind Mike Portnoy Leaving Dream Theater - YouTube
Watch On

But in a new Drumeo video, his surprise is clear when he discovers that Max – who was in his own prog metal band, Next To None, at the time – has no recollection of what happened. And Max, in turn, looks a little embarrassed to be admitting it to his dad.

“I straight-up do not remember it at all,” he says, explaining that he recently discussed it with sister Melody. “And I was like, old enough – I was about 10 years old, 11?”

Avenged Sevenfold - Nightmare [Official Music Video] - YouTube Avenged Sevenfold - Nightmare [Official Music Video] - YouTube
Watch On

“It’s kind of crazy,” says Max, repeating: “I don’t remember at all.”

“It’s weird that you can remember tours from when you were like, six years old,” Mike reflects.

Max does recall his dad playing him a section of A7X track A Little Piece of Heaven and telling him, “I’m playing with these guys now.” His reaction was “Okay, cool!” – but he still has no recollection of the DT situation.

“Not to get too into it,” Mike says, “but you guys were on tour with me. You guys spent a week with me when I was out with Avenged Sevenfold. We had a separate bus… You did a bunch of shows on the East Coast and we had a day off in New York City. That’s when I met with Dream Theater, and you guys were with me.

“I had the meeting with those guys to let them know that – well, at that time I just wanted a break. I told them what I was feeling and what I was hoping for and hoping we would agree to. But in any case you guys were with me when that happened.”

Max continues to look lost: “I don’t remember! I was thinking about it – how do I not remember?”

“Yeah,” Dad says – and then, after another denial from Max, he adds: “Wow…”

Dream Theater - Overture 1928 / Strange Déjà Vu (Quarantième Live à Paris) - YouTube Dream Theater - Overture 1928 / Strange Déjà Vu (Quarantième Live à Paris) - YouTube
Watch On
Freelance Online News Contributor

Not only is one-time online news editor Martin an established rock journalist and drummer, but he’s also penned several books on music history, including SAHB Story: The Tale of the Sensational Alex Harvey Band, a band he once managed, and the best-selling Apollo Memories about the history of the legendary and infamous Glasgow Apollo. Martin has written for Classic Rock and Prog and at one time had written more articles for Louder than anyone else (we think he's second now). He’s appeared on TV and when not delving into all things music, can be found travelling along the UK’s vast canal network.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.