David Crosby calls Iron Maiden "noise", provokes eloquent response from Testament's Alex Skolnick
The Testament guitarist politely suggests that Crosby go see Iron Maiden live to change his opinion
Select the newsletters you’d like to receive. Then, add your email to sign up.
You are now subscribed
Your newsletter sign-up was successful
Want to add more newsletters?
Every Friday
Louder
Louder’s weekly newsletter is jam-packed with the team’s personal highlights from the last seven days, including features, breaking news, reviews and tons of juicy exclusives from the world of alternative music.
Every Friday
Classic Rock
The Classic Rock newsletter is an essential read for the discerning rock fan. Every week we bring you the news, reviews and the very best features and interviews from our extensive archive. Written by rock fans for rock fans.
Every Friday
Metal Hammer
For the last four decades Metal Hammer has been the world’s greatest metal magazine. Created by metalheads for metalheads, ‘Hammer takes you behind the scenes, closer to the action, and nearer to the bands that you love the most.
Every Friday
Prog
The Prog newsletter brings you the very best of Prog Magazine and our website, every Friday. We'll deliver you the very latest news from the Prog universe, informative features and archive material from Prog’s impressive vault.
Heavy metal, as many of us know, just isn't for everyone. Nevertheless, legendary singer-songwriter David Crosby raised more than a few eyebrows on Twitter last night (October 22) when he publicly described none other than living heavy metal icons Iron Maiden as "noise", prompting a wave of Maiden defenders to arrive in his mentions.
Replying to a Tweet from guitarist and good friend Vin Downes celebrating his first Maiden show since 1986 (Downes noted: "they’re still as tight as ever [and] put on an amazing show"), Crosby remarked, rather bluntly, "It’s so weird to me that you like that noise." This brought out legions of Maiden's fans to point out that Crosby had, perhaps, been a little hasty in his take on the British metal heavyweights - one of which was Testament guitarist Alex Skolnick ,who politely and eloquently suggested that Crosby should perhaps go witness a Maiden show for himself to fully understand their appeal and power.
"David, it has to be experienced live," Skolnick Tweeted back. "The energy is contagious. Let Vin Downes drag you to one of their shows sometime. You might be surprised!"
While Skolnick's own Tweet drew a fair few responses too - some of which suggested that you shouldn't have to go see Iron Maiden to appreciate them - the general consensus certainly seems to be that Crosby may have missed the mark with this one.
For those that do want to catch Iron Maiden live, they recently announced their Future Past tour, which will take them across the UK, Ireland and Europe next summer. Check out the full list of dates for the tour below.
Iron Maiden Future Past tour 2023 dates
Jun 9: Sweden Rock Festival, SWE
Jun 11: Leipzig Quarterback Immobilien Arena, GER
Jun 13: Krakow Tauron Arena, POL
Jun 14: Krakow Tauron Arena, POL
Jun19: Zurich Hallenstadion, SWI
Jun 24: Dublin 3 Arena, IRE
Jun 26: Glasgow OVO Hydro, SCO
Jun 28: Leeds, First Direct Arena, ENG
Jun 30: Manchester AO Arena, ENG
Jul 03: Nottingham Motorpoint Arena, ENG
Jul 04: Birmingham Utilita Arena, ENG
Jul 07: London O2 Arena, ENG
Jul 08: London O2 Arena, ENG
Jun 13: Krakow, Tauron Arena, POL
Jul 11: Amsterdam Ziggo Dome, HOL
Jul 13: Antwerp Sportpaleis, BEL
Jul 15: Milan, The Return of The Gods Festival, ITA
Jul 25: Dortmund Westfalenhalle, GER
Jul 29: Frankfurt Festhalle, GER
Jul 31: Munich Olympiahalle, GER
Aug 2-5: Wacken Open Air Festival, GER
Best concert ticket sites: Our pick for live music and beyond
It’s so weird to me that you like that noise https://t.co/54x6tlgonZOctober 23, 2022
David, it has to be experienced live. The energy is contagious. Let @vindownes drag you to one of their shows sometime. You might be surprised! 🤷October 23, 2022
Sign up below to get the latest from Classic Rock, plus exclusive special offers, direct to your inbox!

Merlin was promoted to Executive Editor of Louder in early 2022, following over ten years working at Metal Hammer. While there, he served as Online Editor and Deputy Editor, before being promoted to Editor in 2016. Before joining Metal Hammer, Merlin worked as Associate Editor at Terrorizer Magazine and has written for Classic Rock, Rock Sound, eFestivals and others. Across his career he has interviewed legends including Ozzy Osbourne, Lemmy, Metallica, Iron Maiden (including getting a trip on Ed Force One courtesy of Bruce Dickinson), Guns N' Roses, KISS, Slipknot, System Of A Down and Meat Loaf. He has also presented and produced the Metal Hammer Podcast, presented the Metal Hammer Radio Show and is probably responsible for 90% of all nu metal-related content making it onto the site.
