"The heavier it gets, the more you think someone else did this better." Five songwriters usher in confusion on debut Moby Grape album

Moby Grape's debut album could have set them on the road to stardom. Instead, it sent them down a confusing cul-de-sac

Moby Grape in 1967
(Image credit: © PopImages/Alamy)

You can trust Louder Our experienced team has worked for some of the biggest brands in music. From testing headphones to reviewing albums, our experts aim to create reviews you can trust. Find out more about how we review.

Moby Grape - Moby Grape

Moby Grape debut album cover

(Image credit: Columbia Records)

Hey Grandma
Mr. Blues
Fall On You
8:05
Come In The Morning
Omaha
Naked, If I Want To
Someday
Ain't No Use
Sitting By The Window
Changes
Lazy Me
Indifference

The first album from San Francisco quartet Moby Grape flew directly in the face of the Summer of Love, eschewing hippie bullshit for fizzy songs that bucked and roared like the Rolling Stones or Buffalo Springfield. It was a record that should have set them off on a long career.

Alas, bad luck, record-company ineptitude and self-sabotage (drummer Don Stevenson is giving the finger on the original LP sleeve) served to undermine them from the get-go. And that wasn't all.

“Every song was just amazing," REO Speedwagon's Kevin Cronin told Classic Rock. "I loved the jangly guitar sound they had, and also the excellent vocals. All the songs on the album were released as a single on the same day, which diluted the commercial potential and ensured the band didn’t have the big hit they deserved."

"They were trying to make a statement that every song was a great hit single," Stevie Van Zant told us. "But, man, it killed the band."

Lightning bolt page divider

Every week, Album of the Week Club listens to and discusses the album in question, votes on how good it is, and publishes our findings, with the aim of giving people reliable reviews and the wider rock community the chance to contribute.

Join the group now.

Other albums released in June 1967

  • David Bowie - David Bowie
  • Insight Out - The Association
  • Small Faces - Small Faces
  • Evolution - The Hollies
  • Hip Hug-Her - Booker T & the M.G.'s
  • Leonard Nimoy Presents Mr. Spock's Music from Outer Space - Leonard Nimoy
  • Side Trips - Kaleidoscope
  • We Are Paintermen - The Creation

What they said...

"San Francisco rock at its '67 peak, this is genuine hippie power pop. Moby Grape sang like demons and wrote crisp songs packed with lysergic country-blues excitement, while the band's three guitarists – Jerry Miller, Peter Lewis and Skip Spence – created a network of lightning." (Rolling Stone)

"Harmonies run from sweet to intense, guitars likewise. Fast ones like the begin-with-a-bang Hey Grandma" and Spence's anthemic Omaha rock as hard as the grungiest garage classics. Yet slow ones like the beseeching 8:05 and the resigned Sitting By The Window stand alongside the loveliest tunes in the country-rock canon this album initiated." (Robert Christgau)

"As songwriters, Moby Grape blended straight-ahead rock & roll, smart pop, blues, country, and folk accents into a flavorful brew that was all their own, with a clever melodic sense that reflected the lysergic energy surrounding them without drowning in it." (Allmusic)

What you said...

Fraser Fisher: I guess I'm a little different than most, as I'm very familiar with this album thanks to an older sibling. I still have an original copy of this album that I enjoy listening to once in a while, and it always brings back childhood memories for me, playing Hey Grandma relentlessly on my little Seabreeze record player as a little kid.

Probably their best album, as this band was plagued with bad management and drugs and soon fell out of fashion; though they did regroup a few times and recorded a few more LPs, they never really recovered.

Skip Spence was the first to fall following a path much like Syd Barrett did. Though he did get back into the music business before his death, he never really came to fruition. He did write songs while he was in a mental institution recovering for an album called Oar, a very strange album indeed.

Regardless of their problems, I don't think they would have probably survived much further than the early seventies, with things changing in the music industry away from that sort of Laurel Canyon West Coast sound. But as I said, it's an album I enjoy listening to once in a while, and it's kind of neat to have an original copy, even though it's a little worse for wear. A little interesting tidbit about the album is that on the front cover of the original pressing, the drummer, Don Stevenson, is seen giving the finger on the washboard, and apparently the record company didn't like that, so they airbrushed it out shortly after the initial release.

John Davidson: I managed to piece ( or should it be peace) the album together on YouTube from various compilations, etc., but that was largely where the fun ended. Moby Grape sound like every late 60s flower power band at the same time. So much so that I wondered if they had inspired Spinal Tap's Listen To The Flower People.

They switch from psychedelic pop to Californian blues to Creedence Clearwater Revival-style swamp rock, and then to Beach Boys harmonies before landing on Smokey Robinson pop, which certainly shows how the band had a range of talents available, but the downside is that they lack focus and identity.

I'm not sure if it shows supreme confidence or the exact opposite to dabble in five genres in as many tracks on your debut album.

As a sampler of what was going on in late 60s pop rock, it's an interesting document, but as an album it's not something I feel likely to reach for again. A curio, but not an essential one.

Moby Grape - Hey Grandma - Monterey Pop Festival - 1967 - YouTube Moby Grape - Hey Grandma - Monterey Pop Festival - 1967 - YouTube
Watch On

Philip Qvist: The joys of the 60s and the habit at the time of releasing different versions of the same album in different countries. The version that I was listening to clearly had songs missing from the playlist, as per Wikipedia. Not that it mattered, because Moby Grape left me a bit underwhelmed.

I guess when you have a band where all five band members could write and sing songs, then you can expect an album with a lot of variety, but also with the risk of the record turning into an inconsistent one in the process. Sometimes too much of a good thing can be bad for you, and Moby Grape (the album) is proof of that.

It's an okay album, but it's not one that will become a regular on my playlist. There were far better albums than this that came out in 1967. A 6/10 this week.

Mike Canoe: Like many other Summer of Love/Woodstock bands, it seems almost an obligation to go back and revisit a band like Moby Grape. Next year is going to be one seminal album after another celebrating its 60th birthday, so at least Moby Grape got in ahead of the rush. Unfortunately, it's all too central casting "hippie rock band" for me and not enough garage rock grunt. I find myself not even liking most of the vocal harmonies, which may be a first. 8:05 and Omaha stand out, but the rest is a jumble with not enough rumble.

Adam Ranger: Moby Grape are a band I know of, but have heard little. On listening to this, what do I get?

Nice harmonies, jangly guitars, bluesy rock and some country rock that take you back to an earlier time (Although I was only 2 years old when it was released). It's not bad, but perhaps lacks an identity: Five lead singers (all songwriters) probably contribute to that feel. Many songs are only two minutes long, and the whole album is short enough not to get bored.

If I want jangly guitars, my go-tos are The Byrds or Buffalo Springfield. For blues and harmony, it's CSN&Y (Deja Vu, to be precise). So this Moby Grape album is interesting and listenable, but it's not essential listening.

Chris Elliott: That's an odd album. The problem when you have five songwriters is you get a random selection.

One minute we're doing jangle pop psychedelia, then we're a heavy blues band with a bit of jangle, but then we want to be MC5... and then we're off into country rock. The heavier it gets, the more you think someone else did this better: the jangle psych is fine, but it's not the Byrds or Alex Chilton; the country rock is pleasant but, again, forgettable.

It's not essential. But it's interesting. I'll give it that.

Greg Schwepe: Being a big Zeppelin fan, I’ve long known that Robert Plant was a fan of Moby Grape, but had never checked them out. Seeing that my Spotify version said Moby Grape (with Bonus Tracks), I wanted to find out which tracks were on the original album and which were the bonus tracks since they weren’t really clearly marked. And in doing some internet sleuthing, I found that the original release had 13 tracks, while the current Spotify version has eight tracks; only three of which were on the original album. I’m sooooo confused! (Turns out I was not the only “Expert Reviewer” to have this problem!)

But it turns out it didn’t make much difference. Because after listening, it left me a little indifferent anyway, no matter what version I would have listened to. While I have heard similar bands from this era (but totally can’t remember them now!) that I liked, Moby Grape did not leave a big impression.

I will say “Indifference” might have been the one track that stuck with me a little, with its wiggly lead guitar. And looking back at my notes next to the remaining song titles I had written down, I found I had written down nothing half the time! Oops. No comments to refer back to.

Nothing I really disliked, but nothing that would ever make me listen again. Wait… what was the album that was picked this week? Totally forgot. 6 out of 10 on this one for me. Whatever it was.

Final score: 6.78 (23 votes cast, total score 156)

Join the Album Of The Week Club on Facebook to join in. The history of rock, one album at a time.

Classic Rock Magazine

Classic Rock is the online home of the world's best rock'n'roll magazine. We bring you breaking news, exclusive interviews and behind-the-scenes features, as well as unrivalled access to the biggest names in rock music; from Led Zeppelin to Deep Purple, Guns N’ Roses to the Rolling Stones, AC/DC to the Sex Pistols, and everything in between. Our expert writers bring you the very best on established and emerging bands plus everything you need to know about the mightiest new music releases.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.