Gavin Harrison: Cheating The Polygraph

It’s Porcupine Tree, but not as we know it…

Why you can trust Louder Our expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing products and services so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about how we test.

Gavin Harrison’s long harboured desire to re-record some of his favourite Porcupine Tree songs has produced far more than a glorified covers album with a bit of flashy drumming (although there are drums aplenty).

At its heart, Cheating The Polygraph is an instrumental big band jazz album – a steaming rhythm section, a world-class collection of horn players, melodic playfulness and astounding syncopated ensemble performances. Imagining the late-70s Buddy Rich Big Band, adding hints of Zappa, Prokofiev, Stravinsky, Bernstein and Quincy Jones, wouldn’t be going far wrong, but the overall effect transcends such a crude listing of influences. There’s funk of the slow, sultry variety (Heart Attack In A Layby, Creator Had A Mastertape) and of the more hard grooving, punchy kind (Hatesong), and there’s more than a hint of West Side Story in The Pills I’m Taking. Although carrying Harrison’s name, the album owes as much to the talents of bass player and arranger Laurence Cottle, whose work in deconstructing the source material is simply mesmerising. Whatever label you wish to give it, music this complex and multi-layered deserves your attention.

Gary Mackenzie

Gary has contributed reviews and news features for Prog Magazine for over a decade now. A fan of prog and heavy rock since childhood, his main areas of interest are classic and symphonic prog, prog-metal and modern acts bringing in fresh influences to the genre. He has a professional background in youth and community work, he teaches drum kit in schools and is a working musician. Gary was the drummer in semi-legendary NWOBHM band Praying Mantis for a couple of years and has been a member of indie-prog-pop-art-rock combo The Mighty Handful for more than twenty years. He loves cats and skiing, and has a Blue Peter badge.