Today, the sound of metalcore is one of the most universally recognisable styles in modern heavy metal. We’ve come to accept it as one of our most prolific sub-genres, with its own set of well-worn tropes. Back in 2004, however, it was only just beginning to come into true prominence, and although there was an exciting crop of new, young artists ready to smash through the glass ceiling, the world needed a band to give that scene the crossover anthem it deserved. Enter: Killswitch Engage.
“Obviously, this was our first album with Howard [Jones, former Killswitch frontman who replaced the outgoing Jesse Leach at the time] and we knew what a great singer he was, so why the hell wouldn’t we utilise that?” Killswitch guitarist Adam D tells us when we ask him about the creation of the tune that would send his band stratospheric. “The song came together really easily. To be honest, I didn’t have to change the way that I wrote to incorporate Howard, or think about finding a sound that was more commercial; I just wrote something I thought sounded cool and he came in and made it soar. It just felt huge.”
- Alive Or Just Breathing: how Killswitch Engage saved metal from itself
- The Top 10 best proto-metalcore records
- The 50 best Metallica songs of all time
- Paul Gray: the life and death of Slipknot’s quiet genius
The song Adam is referring to is the title track from Killswitch Engage’s classic third album, 2004’s The End Of Heartache. The album would serve as the follow-up to the equally excellent Alive Or Just Breathing, which had taken Killswitch from being a group of unknown, underground metal-loving punks to one of the most hyped young bands in the world. The transition had happened quickly, but Adam recalls that his band learnt to grow very quickly.
“When I think back to the early days of playing heavy music in little bars around the Boston area, I genuinely don’t think I could have written a song like The End Of Heartache back then,” he admits. “I’m not sure I would have been capable of doing it. We needed to have had experience playing those bigger stages and learning what worked live before I could have tackled something like that.”
With the experience of touring to an ever-expanding fanbase on the Alive Or Just Breathing tour, and with Howard now firmly settled in his role after stepping into Jesse’s shoes in late 2002, the new-look Killswitch were aware they needed to evolve.
“We knew that people were expecting something from us,” Adam smiles. “But I’ve never felt the pressure from that, I’m always just delighted that people care about our band. But we did want to try and do something that we had never really done before, something that would translate to a huge amount of people.”
The End Of Heartache turned out to be the song they were looking for: a slow-building epic that eschewed the Killswitch sound of savage metallic hardcore for an altogether more anthemic vibe, Howard’s gargantuan vocal hook giving a whole new set of dynamics to the band. Ironically, Adam doesn’t remember it standing out from the rest of the material they had been working on.
“We liked it, but we had no idea it was going to be the definitive one,” he says. It wasn’t until the song’s debut live performances that the band realised it was hitting the right notes.
“When we first played it live, the reaction was crazy,” remembers Adam. “By the second verse the entire crowd were singing along with it. It just seemed to get a bigger and bigger reaction the longer we went.”
Asked why the song held such mass appeal, Adam is quick to once again lay credit at the feet of Howard.
“I love Jesse’s lyrics, I think they’re incredibly powerful, but when Howard came into the band he brought a new energy,” he says. “It was a lot more about feelings, lost love, digging into your heartache. It wasn’t as esoteric as Jesse. The crowds started to change a lot: we started seeing more girls coming, which was great!”
The first official single to be released from the new album had been the more aggressive Rose Of Sharyn (When Darkness Falls had previously appeared on the soundtrack to 2003 slasher Freddy Vs Jason), but it soon became apparent to the band’s label that the title track was a crossover success waiting to happen. Still, even though this was a much more melodic-sounding Killswitch Engage track, there was the matter of polishing up the song for mainstream consumption, with a radio edit stripping the song’s screamed vocals for an even cleaner version. That’s something that still rankles with Adam all these years later.
“Yeah, I really fought against that,” he chuckles. “It seems insane to imagine it now, but back then the idea of having any type of screaming on the radio was just an immediate no-go, so we were convinced to do it. I guess it worked out pretty well, because you see the success of the song, but I really didn’t like that: I like to hear a song as it was intended by the artist. I don’t want someone coming in afterwards and making it sound more like how they would want it. That didn’t sit right with me, and I very much doubt I’d let that happen again.”
As Adam rightly concedes, the edit didn’t harm the song’s trajectory at all: it went on to give the band their first Grammy nomination for Best Metal Performance and was picked up to be featured on horror sequel Resident Evil: Apocalypse’s original soundtrack. That was something Adam describes as a “Pretty odd, pretty cool thing to be on… although I have no idea if it did anything for our career.”
Unquestionably. It’s a song that has become one of, if not the most iconic Killswitch single ever. Arriving at a time when the new breed of bands were looking to branch out and expand their sound, Killswitch Engage provided a blueprint for the next generation of metalcore bands to conquer the scene.
“I don’t know how influential it’s been to other bands,” shrugs Adam. “I do certainly think that it represented the next step in our career, though. It was kind of like a signpost to where we were going to go. Is it our most important song? It’s certainly one of them. I do wonder how different our career would have been if it hadn’t taken off like that, so, yeah, maybe it’s the key one.”
Despite this admittance, Adam does add that he hasn’t always enjoyed playing it live, even though it remains a staple of the band’s shows.
“I like playing the song live if people are into it,” he laughs. “If people are standing there saying, ‘What is this shit?’ it’s not so much fun. Any song is fun to play if you see your crowd digging it. But we did actually drop it out of the set for a little while a few years back; we were getting kind of fatigued by it and we just needed to let it rest for a while. We all knew it would come back, but sometimes you just need to have a little breather and approach it fresh.”
According to Adam, the song received its shot in the arm for him once again when Jesse rejoined the band in 2012.
“A song does take on new forms and new meanings when it is being sung by someone else,” he notes. “Jesse came in and does a great job, just like Howard did on Jesse’s songs, interpreting that song in his own unique way. It felt great hearing him sing it from the first time we jammed it. He really killed it on all of the other material, but he brings a very different intensity to that particular song, which is amazing to see.”
- These are the rock’n’roll Face masks we’ll be wearing to stay safe
- Block out noise with the best budget noise-cancelling headphones
- Best record players: turntables your vinyl collection deserves
- The best bluetooth speakers you can buy right now
These days, the debates over who is the definitive Killswitch vocalist seems to have simmered down, especially after Howard’s appearance on their latest album, Atonement. Killswitch fans have, in the main, spent time celebrating two superb vocalists. There was, however, a very special performance in 2019 of The End Of Heartache, at London’s O2 Arena while supporting Iron Maiden, where Howard stepped out onstage with his former bandmates to the delight of everyone present.
“Howard was doing some Jasta shows in the UK and he came to see us,” smiles Adam. “We were sitting backstage and we decided to do a song, and that just felt like the right one for us to do. We loved doing it, it was actually very emotional for me. I had all kinds of memories come flooding back, and to see the reaction, there and online afterwards, was just really beautiful. It means a lot to all of us that the song still means so much to so many people all these years later.”
That it does, and you can’t see it changing. The End Of Heartache is still an anthem, a landmark and a key song to the growth of metalcore 15 years down the line.