Roger Waters: Is this the life he really wants?

A shot of Roger Waters performing live
Waters performing The Wall at Olympiastadion, Berlin, on September 4, 2013 (Image credit: Adam Berry\/Getty Images)

It’s been nearly a quarter of a century since Roger Waters released his last solo album proper [1992’s Amused To Death]. In that time he’s become the top-grossing touring solo artist with his immense Wall spectacular, and even reunited with his old Pink Floyd buddies/sparring partners for 2005’s Live 8 concert in Hyde Park.

In 2010, when announcing The Wall shows, which began in arenas and ended up in the world’s biggest stadia, he announced: “I’m not as young as I used to be… But I still have a fire in my belly and I have something to say.” This is certainly true, seven years on, with Is This The Life We Really Want?, his fourth solo venture. As one might expect, Waters is still an angry man, railing over some fine Nigel Godrich-produced music at the world around him. Still exasperated at the injustice he sees on every level of life, if you dig Waters’ themes, which let’s face it, haven’t really changed that much since his Animals-led tirade at humanity back in 1977, the current caustic state of the planet gives the 73-year old plenty to rage at.

Yet there’s a sensitivity on the album that previously hadn’t surfaced in his output, although journalists of late have often remarked at what a different man he seems to be from the one who’d tried to sue his old bandmates, incredulous they’d even consider carrying on without him. Of course if you scratch that particular wound he’ll still bite, but as we saw at the launch of Pink Floyd’s Their Mortal Remains exhibition currently taking place at London’s V&A museum, it is now handled with a slightly exasperated sense of humour. And let’s face it, the old “Will you ever…?” question is pretty wearisome these days when we all know what the answer is anyway.

So has rock’s greatest curmudgeon softened in his old age? Well, if you listen to the plaintive Wait For Her one might think so; it’s a love song sat amongst the tirade against the world we’ve created for ourselves. Waters is a man who hardly needs poking with a stick to vent his spleen, and the current state of the world gives him more than enough ammunition.

One of the many exhibits at the V&A’s Pink Floyd exhibition, Their Mortal Remains, which runs until October 1

One of the many exhibits at the V&A’s Pink Floyd exhibition, Their Mortal Remains, which runs until October 1 (Image credit: Stufish /Pink Floyd exhibition)

Yet as we saw the night before we sat down to talk with him, at the TimesTalks evening at New York’s Florence Gould Hall, ironically just around the corner from Trump Tower, he is in startlingly good form for what Prog’s reviewer [see page 108] pretty accurately calls an “irascible genius”.

“I think it’s the question of giving myself my due,” he muses. “You know that guy who asked me that question about the judge on the shoulder? And I gave him a perfectly reasonable and fairly eloquent answer, because I know exactly the feeling that we all carry this judge around and it’s going: ‘Nee, nee, nee, nee.’

“And all through my career – particularly, though, in the aftermath of that Pink Floyd thing, which was hugely important. I was in that band for 20 years or whatever it was, but there was a lot of baggage, you know? It was a bit like driving away from a dodgy wedding with cans dragging behind the car rattling all the time.”

Did you feel you were made responsible for the break-up of Pink Floyd?

There was a huge amount of enmity, you know? And I will probably never be forgiven for all the work that I did, particularly by the other guys who were in the band. But we’re all dying so who gives a fuck, really? It’s whatever. It took me a while to get over that and stop worrying about trying to figure out what people had problems about stuff. All that crap about, “He wouldn’t let us write.” Fuck you! [Laughs] Nobody can stop you writing, dopey. Or whoever you are. It’s ridiculous. I don’t want to get into it because you can hear I feel quite jolly about it, but I’m just sick of it. I’ve left it behind me. I don’t usually talk about it because… And I won’t talk about it any more now. I’m done.

So you’re in a different state of mind these days?

Well, I had no idea that I was going to be able to succeed. Because I had had the whole Pink Floyd audience turn their back on me in 1987 when they started to tour again. I was playing to tiny audiences and there was a lot of, you know… Bleurgh. [Laughingly makes a vomiting noise.]

Brothers In Arms: reunited at 2005’s Live 8 show at Hyde Park. L-R: David Gilmour, Roger Waters, Nick Mason and Rick Wright

Brothers In Arms: reunited at 2005’s Live 8 show at Hyde Park. L-R: David Gilmour, Roger Waters, Nick Mason and Rick Wright (Image credit: Mick Hutson/Getty Images)

People certainly seem to have changed their minds about you. They’re certainly aware of who you are and what you do these days.

Yeah, they seem to have figured some of it out. And this record, I think, is helping them to figure it out, because people that have heard the record, the whole thing, are going “Wow!” [Chuckles]

You certainly make it clear on Is This The Life We Really Want?


But you’re also looking to the future, which is important.

It is, yes.

How many other musicians that are in their 70s are still making albums that make such salient and prudent points? You’re not just doing an album of old blues covers.

I’m not. Or Sinatra covers [chuckles], like Bob. Bless him.

So why has it taken you almost 25 years to actually write and record a new studio album?

I don’t know. Like I said last night, writing the song Déjà Vu was a catalyst, a starting point for some of that. And also, as I say, I derived encouragement from the work of certain documentary filmmakers. I mentioned Jeremy Scahill and his movie Dirty Wars. And also the extraordinary fortitude and courage of Chelsea Manning and Edward Snowden and Ray McGovern and Daniel Ellsberg and all the other whistleblowers that have emerged from the ashes of the Vietnam War. I know that was a long time ago, but one takes courage from all of that. You see people behaving properly and you think: “Wow, I’d like to be part of the blowing of the whistle,” even if it’s only be writing a poem or writing a song or making a record or whatever it might be.

Fresh-Faced: the band in 1971, long before the walls went up

Fresh-Faced: the band in 1971, long before the walls went up (Image credit: Hipgnosis/Storm Thorgerson/Aubrey Powell/Pink Floyd Archive)

Originally there’d been talk about the song Heartland being released in 2008…


You were already thinking about an album then?


And some of these new songs date back to the 20082010 period?

Yes, they do. You know, there’s still lines in a song that I wrote back then, which I’ve still never recorded. There’s a line in it that sounds pretty cynical, but I kind of like it. There’s a line at the end of the song that goes: ‘And the man who sold his kids for meat to a broker in Bangkok and got a colour TV, and the keys to the executive washroom and a space in the company parking lot.’

Like selling his soul for all that crap?

That’s some nice writing, because it says a lot about commerce and how we become slaves to commerce, particularly in the US. But this, the idea of commerce being as important as it has become and spreading all over… the model, the American model. When World War II was over, we could have picked over them broken bones, we could have been free, but we chose to adhere to abundance. We chose the American dream, and that is the American dream. And if you have to sell your kids for meat to a broker in Bangkok, Trump would approve of that. It’s business. Or somebody else’s kids. I mean, he might not sell his own kids, though you sense that they’re like lumps of meat when you see them parading around. They’re like prize cattle. They’ve sort of been plumped up. Those Trump boys, they look as if they’ve been injected with hormones every morning before breakfast to get them that pumped up and kind of dopey.

(Image credit: © Roger Waters 1978)

We don’t know that they haven’t been!

We don’t know, no. We don’t know.

You live in New York. What keeps you here in the Trump era with things so seemingly bad? Do you feel like the voice of opposition? Leading the resistance?

There’s a lot of people resisting this bullshit, luckily. It’s also convenience. I moved here because my youngest kid was here. And then I sort of stayed and I went through another marriage and stuff. And you gather the detritus of life around you and it’s easy to get stuck. But I’m not unhappy here. And New York – you can walk a lot of places in New York. I’ve recently taken to using the subway a lot, because it’s much faster than going anywhere in a car or a taxi. Actually, I like it on the subway. I like being kind of crushed - or not crushed. I often travel in the middle of the day, and it’s nice when there’s not many people there. But it’s nice to sit there and look at the other people. You see who lives in this city and how diverse it is, how cosmopolitan it is.

The new album, Is This The Life We Really Want?, is also about love, isn’t it?


At least two or three songs are. Wait For Her reads like a manual for a better relationship. Like: “This is what I’ve got to do, and you’d better not mess up”?

Actually it’s very specific. It’s a poem. It’s based on a translation of a poem by Mahmoud Darwish, the famous Palestinian poet. And the poem, in its title, has the words ‘Kama Sutra’. It is actually specifically about waiting for a woman to orgasm. That’s what it’s about. I had no idea when I first heard it and when I started writing this song, but that’s what it is. And it’s beautiful. He is great… I knew nothing about him and then I discovered him, and his poetry is extraordinary.

Then there’s a song called Broken Bones where you’re clearing your throat in the beginning.

I did clear my throat before when singing one day, and Nigel Godrich just left it in. One does clear one’s throat from time to time when one’s singing. [Laughs]

Godrich is an interesting choice for a producer. You had a production hand in your three previous solo albums. What made you pass this time round?

I might have been tempted. I don’t really remember, but it feels good. I think he’s done a great job, so I couldn’t have made this album on my own. Well, I could have done, but it would’ve been completely different. So I’m really glad that I did relinquish control. I’ve never done it before. I may never do it again, but I’m glad I did it this once at least.

Last night you hinted that you’re already thinking about your next album. Is that because you’ve written so many songs over the years?

I’ve got tonnes and tonnes of material, yeah. And when I next make a record, I don’t know. I have to, at some point, release a recording of the other half of Déjà Vu which I recited a verse of last night: ‘If I had been God, I would not have chosen anyone. I would’ve laid an even hand on all my children. Everyone would have been content to forgo Ramadan and time better spent in the company of friends, breaking bread and mending nets.’

Is This The Life We Really Want? is released on June 2 via Columbia. See The Pink Floyd Exhibition: Their Mortal Remains is on now at the V&A until October 1. For more information see

Roger Waters - Is This The Life We Really Want? album review

Roger Waters releases poignant video for The Last Refugee

How Roger Waters rebuilt The Wall