City Boy: Reissues

First four albums split over two releases from one-hit wonders.

You can trust Louder Our experienced team has worked for some of the biggest brands in music. From testing headphones to reviewing albums, our experts aim to create reviews you can trust. Find out more about how we review.

Most bands see their failure to become megastars as attributable, not to a lack of talent, but to their record label’s incompetence. That’s an argument unavailable to City Boy.

Having signed to Vertigo in 1974 they were assigned a young ‘Mutt’ Lange to work on their albums. However, despite the future uber producer’s best efforts – acknowledged by the band in the sleeve notes – it wasn’t until fourth album Book Early that they had a hit with karaoke classic

These no-frills reissues highlight these deficiencies. Pleasant as it is, their self-titled 1975 debut (510) never establishes a firm identity, despite the record’s accomplished nods to funk, prog rock and AOR. With punk on the horizon, the follow up, 1976’s Dinner At The Ritz, (510), smacks of a band already past their sell-by-date – not least on a syrupy, seven-minute The Violin.

If 1977’s Young Men Gone West (610) has its moments – notably swaggering glam stomp Bad For Business – it’s not until 1978’s Book Early (610) that everything finally clicks. A tightrope-taut pop classic, became a Top 10 hit, showing off both Lange’s production genius and the vocal skills of drummer Roy Ward – who he had promoted to centre stage.

Alas, Lange’s subsequent exit after fifth album – 1979’s The Day The Earth Caught Fire – effectively ended their career, despite two more albums.

Paul Moody is a writer whose work has appeared in the Classic Rock, NME, Time Out, Uncut, Arena and the Guardian. He is the co-author of The Search for the Perfect Pub and The Rough Pub Guide.