Legend Of The Seagullmen - Legend Of The Seagullmen album review

Aquatic tales of blood and horror, straight from Davy Jones’s locker

Cover art for Legend Of The Seagullmen - Legend Of The Seagullmen

You can trust Louder Our experienced team has worked for some of the biggest brands in music. From testing headphones to reviewing albums, our experts aim to create reviews you can trust. Find out more about how we review.

Of all the genre mash-ups you could possibly imagine for a new progmetal supergroup to get their teeth into, a nautical spaghetti western concept album would seem like a project destined to founder on the rocks and sink without trace. And yet the music created by guitarist Brent Hinds (Mastodon), drummer Danny Carey (Tool), bassist Peter Griffin (Zappa Plays Zappa) and filmmaker/guitarist Jimmy Heyward (among various others), based on an idea from vocalist David ‘The Doctor’ Dreyer, is extraordinary, original and ridiculously enjoyable.

Sounding a bit like a salty sea dog Carl McCoy fronting the Dawnrazor-era Nephilim, Dreyer’s menacing style, detailed approach to lore and freakish characters propel the album forward relentlessly, while Hinds and co. make with the Fistful Of Dollars-style metal; The Orca, Curse Of The Red Tide and The Fogger are all superb, but the standout must be atmospheric closer The Ballad Of The Deep Sea Diver, which goes for the absurdly wonderful, full galloping orchestral film score treatment.

Looking utterly bonkers on paper, Legend Of The Seagullmen shouldn’t work at all, yet it’s an early highlight of 2018.

Essi Berelian

Whether it’s magazines, books or online, Essi has been writing about rock ’n’ metal for around thirty years. He has been reviews editor for Classic Rock and Metal Hammer, rock reviews editor for lads mag Front and worked for Kerrang!. He has also written the Rough Guide to Heavy Metal and contributed to the Rough Guide to Rock and Rough Guide Book of Playlists, and the Guinness Book of British Hit Singles (13th edition). Most fun interview? Tenacious D – Jack Black and Kyle Gass – for The Pick of Destiny movie book. An avid record/CD/tape collector, he’s amassed more music than he could ever possibly listen to, which annoys his wife no end.