The Vicar: Songbook #1

Another music from a different clergy.

Why you can trust Louder Our expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing products and services so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about how we test.

Taking over where Eleanor Rigby left off, Songbook #1 replaces the traditional rock’n’roll rhythm section with a string quintet and imposes a similar ban on amplified instruments and percussion in favour of brass and woodwind arrangements.

Once you’re past the novelty aspect, the album becomes compelling, particularly as you realise the songs could have had a conventional ‘rock’ treatment but the different setting alters the way you listen to them. Not that the album does itself any favours: the first few songs are more angular than melodic and the strummed acoustic guitar at the start of track four arrives as a familiar relief.

There’s no bias against technology when it comes to recording, however, and the 5.1 mix on the accompanying DVD is sumptuous. The problems arise with the half a dozen different singers, including ‘lost’ soul boy Lewis Taylor and Andy (brother of Thom) Yorke, that disturbs the album’s continuity. And then there’s the wilfully enigmatic nature of The Vicar himself – a good friend of Robert Fripp, apparently – that is an unnecessary distraction.

Hugh Fielder has been writing about music for 47 years. Actually 58 if you include the essay he wrote about the Rolling Stones in exchange for taking time off school to see them at the Ipswich Gaumont in 1964. He was news editor of Sounds magazine from 1975 to 1992 and editor of Tower Records Top magazine from 1992 to 2001. Since then he has been freelance. He has interviewed the great, the good and the not so good and written books about some of them. His favourite possession is a piece of columnar basalt he brought back from Iceland.